Gamification of Joint Student/System Control Over Problem Selection in a Linear Equation TutorYanjin Long, Vincent Aleven
Publikationsdatum:


Diese Seite wurde seit 4 Jahren inhaltlich nicht mehr aktualisiert. Unter Umständen ist sie nicht mehr aktuell.
Zusammenfassungen
Integrating gamification features in ITSs has become a popular theme in ITSs research. This work focuses on gamification of shared student/system control over problem selection in a linear equation tutor, where the system adaptively selects the problem type while the students select the individual problems. In a 2x2+1+1 classroom experiment with 267 middle school students, we studied the effect, on learning and enjoyment, of two ways of gamifying shared problem selection: performancebased rewards and the possibility to redo completed problems, both common design patterns in games. We also included two ecological control conditions: a standard ITS and a popular algebra game, DragonBox 12+. A novel finding was that of the students who had the freedom to repractice problems, those who were not given rewards performed significantly better on the posttests than their counterparts who received rewards. Also, we found that the students who used the tutors learned significantly more than students who used DragonBox 12+. In fact, the latter students did not improve significantly from pre to posttests on solving linear equations. Thus, in this study the ITS was more effective than a commercial educational game, even one with great popular acclaim. The results suggest that encouraging repractice of previously solved problems through rewards is detrimental to student learning, compared to solving new problems. It also produces design recommendations for incorporating gamification features in ITSs.
Von Yanjin Long, Vincent Aleven im Text Gamification of Joint Student/System Control Over Problem Selection in a Linear Equation Tutor (2014) In the current work, we investigate the effects of gamifying shared student/system control in our linear equation tutor, Lynnette. We investigated two gamification features: giving students the freedom to repractice previously completed problems (not allowed e.g., in standard Cognitive Tutors) and rewards (stars) for each problem based on students’ performance. These features are similar to Angry Birds’ or DragonBox’ problem selection and rewards systems. We hypothesize that 1) the possibility to repractice problems, added to shared control over problem selection will enhance students’ learning and engagement; 2) rewards based on students’ performance on individual problems will also lead to better learning and engagement. Consequently, we created four experimental versions of Lynnette to evaluate the effects of the two gamification features. Moreover, we included two ecological control conditions in the study: a standard ITS and a commercial algebra game. The standard ITS is a control version of Lynnette without any gamification features and with full system control over problem selection (as is common in e.g. Cognitive Tutors). The algebra game is DragonBox, which has attracted substantial public attention for allegedly helping young children learn algebra in a very short period of time [8, 12]. Although DragonBox has been the subject of at least one research study [1], we are not aware of any studies that empirically investigated its effectiveness in teaching algebra. Given the publicity surrounding the game, it would be good to know how educationally effective and engaging it is, compared to technology proven to be effective in helping students learn (i.e., an ITS). We conducted a classroom experiment with 267 middle school students to investigate our hypotheses.
Von Yanjin Long, Vincent Aleven im Text Gamification of Joint Student/System Control Over Problem Selection in a Linear Equation Tutor (2014) Dieses KonferenzPaper erwähnt...
Begriffe KB IB clear  DragonBox, GamificationGamification, Intelligent Tutoring System (ITS)Intelligent Tutoring System, Lernenlearning, Schuleschool 
Dieses KonferenzPaper erwähnt nicht...
Nicht erwähnte Begriffe  LehrerIn, Unterricht 
Tagcloud
Volltext dieses Dokuments
Gamification of Joint Student/System Control Over Problem Selection in a Linear Equation Tutor: Artikel als Volltext (: , 438 kByte) 